Categories:Business Owner StrategiesRetirement Plans for Businesses

Is Your Company’s 401(k) Plan Stalling Promotions?

Micah Alsobrook, CPFA®, MBA ·

Ask most HR leaders a simple question: do you have an employee who would retire tomorrow if they could afford it?

In our experience, almost everyone says yes. Then they start naming people.

That employee is usually good at their job, loyal, and well paid. But they’re staying because they have to, not because they want to. And every year they stay, someone below them waits for a promotion that isn’t opening up.

We call this retirement-lock: when employees who want to retire can’t afford to, and the business pays for it through higher costs, stalled promotions, and turnover among the people it most wants to keep. Many companies have it. Very few have measured it.

Why Is Retirement-Lock a Business Problem?

It’s easy to see retirement savings as a personal matter. The plan exists, the match is there, and what employees do with it is up to them.

But when a large share of your workforce can’t afford to retire, the business pays for it in ways that don’t show up on the retirement plan line of the budget:

  • Higher compensation costs. Long-tenured employees are usually at the top of their pay band.
  • Higher benefit costs. Health coverage for older employees typically costs more.
  • Stalled advancement. When senior people don’t leave, the pipeline behind them backs up. Your strongest mid-career employees notice.
  • Turnover in the wrong places. The people who leave when promotions stall are often the ones you most wanted to keep.

Employers are starting to feel this. In a recent Nationwide survey, plan sponsors named higher benefit and labor costs as their top concerns about delayed retirements, followed by lower morale and fewer advancement opportunities for younger employees.¹

The pressure isn’t easing. PwC’s 2026 Employee Financial Wellness Survey found that only 38% of Gen X employees are confident they’ll be able to retire when they want to.²

What Does Delayed Retirement Cost Employers?

Several firms have tried to put a number on the cost of delayed retirement. Their estimates don’t agree, and that’s worth understanding.

  • Principal estimates the cost at about $103,000 per year for each employee who works past 65, and more than $120,000 in office-based roles.³
  • Prudential put it at more than $50,000 per delayed employee, or roughly 1% to 1.5% of total workforce costs.⁴
  • EY (2024) estimated about $26,000 per participant for each year of delay.¹

Why such a wide range? Each study compares what you pay a long-tenured employee to what you’d pay their replacement, and each makes different assumptions about salary, benefits, and productivity. Your number depends on your workforce.

So don’t take any of these at face value. Run your own. Here’s a rough way to do it:

  1. Count the employees you believe would retire within a year if they could afford to.
  2. Take their average salary plus benefits.
  3. Subtract what you’d expect to pay a replacement or the person promoted into the role, plus their benefits.
  4. Multiply the difference by the number of employees.

It won’t be precise. It doesn’t need to be. Most leaders who do this exercise for the first time are surprised by the result.

Can Employees Just Work Longer?

Many employees plan to solve a savings shortfall by working longer. The data says that plan often fails.

In EBRI’s 2026 Retirement Confidence Survey, 39% of workers said they expect to retire at 70 or later, or never. But 46% of retirees said they left the workforce earlier than planned, often because of a health issue, a disability, or a change at their employer.⁵

So an underprepared workforce creates two problems, not one. Some employees stay longer than they want to. Others are forced out early without enough saved. Neither outcome is good for the employee, and neither is good for the business.

Education Helps. Design Does More.

Most companies respond to low retirement readiness with more education. Another enrollment meeting, another email, another lunch-and-learn. Those have a place, but they rarely change behavior on their own.

What does change behavior is the default. People tend to stay wherever the plan puts them. Vanguard’s 2026 How America Saves report shows 94% participation in plans that automatically enroll employees, compared with 64% in plans where employees have to sign up on their own.⁶

That’s the core idea behind the three changes we see make the biggest difference.

1. Re-enroll everyone, not just new hires. Auto-enrollment usually applies only to new employees. That leaves out the people most likely to be stuck: long-tenured employees who never joined, or who joined years ago at a low rate and never changed it. A one-time re-enrollment brings everyone into the plan at the default rate, with the option to opt out.

2. Set a stronger default and let it grow. A 3% default quietly tells employees that 3% is enough. It isn’t. Many plans now start at 6%, with automatic increases of 1% a year up to 10% or more. Most employees who are going to opt out do it at enrollment, not when the rate steps up.

This matters most for smaller companies. Vanguard found that only 26% of small plans use auto-enrollment, compared with 61% of large plans. Among small plans that do, 3% is still the most common default.⁷

3. Give people a path out. This is the one most plans skip. Some employees have saved enough but don’t know how to turn a balance into a paycheck, so they keep working. Retirement income planning, clear guidance on Social Security and Medicare timing, and phased retirement options can all help employees leave with confidence and on a timeline that works for the business.

A Useful Way to Think About the Cost

Plan sponsors sometimes push back on a higher default or a stronger match because of the cost. That’s fair. But Principal’s analysis found that the total employer contributions over an employee’s entire career often cost less than a single year of that employee delaying retirement.³

That doesn’t mean every plan change pays for itself. It does mean the cost of doing nothing deserves a line in the conversation.

Three Numbers to Pull This Week

If you want to know where you stand, start here:

  1. Your participation rate. What share of eligible employees are contributing?
  2. Your default rate. If you auto-enroll, where do new employees start? If you don’t, that’s your answer.
  3. Your late-career readiness. How many employees are 60 or older with balances that look too low to retire on?

Your recordkeeper or plan advisor should be able to pull all three quickly. If the numbers raise questions, that’s a good reason to review your plan design with your committee.

Retirement plans are usually treated as a benefit. For a lot of companies, they’re also a workforce planning tool that isn’t being used. The employees who can’t afford to leave are already on your payroll. The question is whether your plan is helping the next group avoid the same spot.

Find Out What Retirement-Lock Is Costing You

Most employers we meet have never seen their participation rate, default rate, and late-career readiness side by side. Even fewer have put a dollar figure on the employees who can’t afford to leave. That’s where we start.

Our Retirement Readiness Review is a working session for business owners, CFOs, and HR leaders. In about an hour, we will:

  • Pull your numbers. We work with your recordkeeper to gather participation, deferral, and late-career balance data, so you don’t have to.
  • Estimate your cost. Using your own workforce figures, we’ll show what delayed retirements may be costing you each year.
  • Benchmark your plan. See how your design compares with plans your size, including auto-enrollment, default rates, and match structure.
  • Prioritize the fixes. We’ll show which changes would matter most for your workforce and what each would cost.

You’ll leave with a short written summary you can take to your plan committee or leadership team. There’s no obligation. It works whether or not you have an advisor today, and if your current setup is working well, we’ll tell you that too.

Gatewood serves as a 3(38) investment fiduciary for employer-sponsored retirement plans. We help employers build plans that support their people and their business, from the day an employee enrolls to the day they’re ready to retire.

Your employees who can’t afford to leave are already on payroll. The sooner you know the number, the sooner you can change it.

FREE CONTENT DOWNLOAD Align Your Retirement Goals as a Couple A Step-by-Step Guide to Financial Confidence   


Sources

  1. Emily Boyle, Employees, Plan Sponsors Optimistic About Retirement Planning, but Share Broader Concerns, PLANSPONSOR, September 26, 2025. https://www.plansponsor.com/employees-plan-sponsors-optimistic-about-retirement-planning-but-share-broader-concerns/
  2. PwC, PwC’s 2026 Employee Financial Wellness Survey, PwC, April 14, 2026. https://www.pwc.com/us/en/services/consulting/human-resources/library/employee-financial-wellness-survey.html
  3. Principal Financial Group, 10 Questions Employers Have Been Asking About the Cost of Delayed Retirement, Principal, 2026. https://www.principal.com/businesses/trends-insights/10-questions-employers-have-been-asking-about-cost-delayed-retirement
  4. Lee Barney, Older Workers Unable to Retire Cost Employers $50,000 a Year, PLANSPONSOR, April 11, 2017. https://plansponsor.com/older-workers-unable-to-retire-cost-employers-50000-a-year
  5. Emily Boyle, How Early, Involuntary Retirements Threaten Retirement Plans, PLANSPONSOR, May 19, 2026. https://www.plansponsor.com/how-early-involuntary-retirements-threaten-retirement-plans/
  6. Vanguard, How America Saves 2026, Vanguard, June 2026. https://workplace.vanguard.com/content/dam/inst/iig-transformation/has/2026/pdf/HowAmericaSaves2026.pdf
  7. Edward Rueda, Vanguard: Small Plans Trail Large Plans in Auto-Enrollment Adoption, PLANADVISER, September 30, 2026. https://www.planadviser.com/vanguard-small-plans-trail-large-plans-in-auto-enrollment-adoption/

Important Disclosures:

Content in this material is for general information only and not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. Gatewood Wealth Solutions and LPL Financial do not provide legal or tax advice or services.

All investing involves risk including loss of principal. No strategy assures success or protects against loss.

The opinions voiced in this material are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual.

This information is not intended to be a substitute for specific individualized tax or legal advice. We suggest that you discuss your specific situation with a qualified tax or legal advisor.

Share this article

Related Articles